NOTES ON THE RES GESTAE AND HISTORIOGRAPHICAL VIEWS TOWARDS THE BATTLE OF ADRIANOPLE (378 A.D.)
Abstract
The Battle of Adrianople has been presented as a turning point in history by classical as well as by modern authors. In this paper, classical sources, especially the res gestae, are being set into context together with modern works, trying to point out a balanced view on historical events and their interpretation by historians. Special attention is being paid to legal aspects as the foedus and dedictio within the limits of the Roman ius gentium. In light of the sources, the Roman-Gothic conflict, even if having resulted in a devastating defeat for the Romans, did not yet challenge the ideal of the Roman state as a hegemon power. The Goths did not seek to infiltrate the Roman Empire in order to carve out their own realm, but even after the battle rather sought to gain permanent and secure settlement within the system of the Roman state. This research focuses on a critical analysis of the events as presented in the res gestae by Ammianus Marcellinus.
Keywords
DOI: 10.14795/j.v5i3.337
References
AUERBACH 2003
Auerbach, E., & Trask, W. R. , Mimesis: The representation of reality in Western literature. (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
BOEFT 2018
Boeft, J. ., Drijvers, J. W., Hengst, D. , & Teitler, H. C. , Philological and historical commentary on Ammianus Marcellinus. (Leiden: Brill)
BROWNLEY 1981
Brownley, M., Gibbon’s Artistic and Historical Scope in the Decline and Fall. Journal of the History of Ideas, 42(4), 629-642.
BURKE 2013
Metahistory: before and after, Rethinking History, 17:4, 437-447
CAREY /ALLFREE / CAIRNS 2013
Carey, B. T. /Allfree, J. B. / Cairns, J. ,Warfare in the ancient world. (Barnsley: Pen & Sword Military).
ČEŠKA 1983
Češka, J. , Julians Nichtbeachtung der bösen Vorzeichen bei Ammianus Marcellinus XXIII 1,7 und XXV 2,8. Listy Filologické / Folia Philologica, 106(3), 169-173.
DEMANDT 2013
Demandt, A. , Zeitenwende: Aufsätze zur Spätantike. (Berlin: De Gruyter).
ELBERN 1987
Elbern,S. , Das Gotenmassaker in Kleinasien (378 n. Chr.). Hermes, 115(1), 99-106.
FERGUSON 2010
Ferguson, N., Complexity and Collapse: Empires on the Edge of Chaos. Foreign Affairs, 89(2), 18-32.
FUHRMANN 1998
Fuhrmann, M. , Rom in der Spätantike: Porträt einer Epoche. (Düsseldorf: Artemis & Winkler).
GOFFART 1981
Walter Goffart. , Rome, Constantinople, and the Barbarians. The American Historical Review, 86(2), 275-306.
GOFFART 2010
Goffart, W., Barbarian Tides: The Migration Age and the Later Roman Empire. (Philadelphia : University of Pennsylvania Press).
HEATHER 2005
Heather, P. , The Fall of the Roman Empire. A New History. (Oxford: Pan Macmillian).
HEATHER 2006
Heather, P.J., „Foedera and foederati of the fourth century“. In: From Roman Provinces to Medieval Kingdom, ed. Thomas F.X. Noble, 242-256.
JONES / MARTINDALE/ MORRIS 1971
Jones, A. H. M. / Martindale, J. R./ Morris, J. , The prosopography of the later Roman empire: Vol. 1. (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press).
JONES 1973
Jones, A. H. M. , The later Roman Empire 284-602:Vol 2. (Oxford: Blackwell)
KARLOWKA 1885
Karlowka, O. , Staatsrecht und Rechtsquellen. (Leipzig: Veit).
KULIKOWSKI 2008
Kulikowski, M., Rome’s Gothic wars: From the third century to Alaric. (New York: Cambridge University Press).
LENSKI 2004
Lenski, N, Valens and the Monks: Cudgeling and Conscription as a Means of Social Control. Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 58: 93-117.
LIEBESCHUETZ 2015
Liebeschuetz, J. , East and West in late antiquity: Invasion, settlement, ethnogenesis and conflicts of religion. (Leiden:Brill).
MARTIN 2011
Martin, J. , Spätantike und Völkerwanderung. (München: Oldenbourg Verlag).
MCDONALD 1939
The History of Rome and Italy in the Second Century B.C. Cambridge Historical Journal, 6(2), 124-146
MITCHELL 2015
Mitchell, S. , A history of the later Roman empire, AD 284-641. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
MUTSCHLER 2000
Mutschler, F. , "Virtus" Und Kein Ende? Römische Werte und römische Literatur im 3. und 2. Jahrhundert v. Chr. Poetica, 32(1/2), 23-49.
NUSSBAUM 1952
Nussbaum, A. , The Significance of Roman Law in the History of International Law. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 100(5), 678-687.
PARKER 2010
Parker, N. , Empire as a Geopolitical Figure, Geopolitics, 15(1), 109-132.
PATZEK 1988
Patzek, B. , Die historischen Bedingungen des Fremdverstehens in Tacitus' 'Germania'. Historische Zeitschrift, 247(1), 27-51.
PERIN / KAZANSKI 2011
Perin,P. / Kazanski, M., „Identity and Ethnicity during the Era of Migrations and Barbarian Kingdoms in the Light of Archaeology in Gaul“ . In: Romans, Barbarians, and the Transformation of the Roman World : Cultural Interaction and the Creation of Identity in Late Antiquity. (eds.)R.W Mathison and D. Shanzer
PFEILSCHIFTER 2014Pfeilschifter, R., Die Spätantike: Der eine Gott und die vielen Herrscher. (München.C.H.Beck)
ROSENBERG 1921
Rosenberg, A., Einleitung und Quellenkunde zur römischen Geschichte. (Berlin: Weidmannsche Buchhandlung).
SCHARF 1991
Scharf, R. , Seniores-iuniores und die Heeresteilung des Jahres 364. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik, 89, 265-272.
SEECK 1966
Seeck ,O. (1966). Geschichte des Untergangs der Antiken Welt. Fünfter Band. (Stuttgart: J.B. Metzlersche Verlagsbuchandlung).
SIVAN 1987
Sivan, H. , On Foederati, Hospitalitas, and the Settlement of the Goths in A.D. 418. The American Journal of Philology, 108(4), 759-772.
SØBY 2012
Søby, C. A., Cassiodorus Jordanes and the history of the Goths: Studies in a migration myth. (København: Museum Tusculanum Press).
SOMMER 2010
Sommer, M. ,Die Soldatenkaiser. (Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft).
THEUWS 2009
Theuws, F. ,“Grave goods, ethnicity, and the rhetoric of burial rites in Late Antique Northern Gaul.” In : Ethnic Constructs in Antiquity: The Role of Power and Tradition (Eds.) T.Derks & N. Roymans, 283-320.
THOMPSON 2002
Thompson, E. A. , Romans and barbarians: The decline of the Western Empire. (Madison/Wis: Univ. of Wisconsin Press)
VOGT 1943
Vogt, J. , Vom Reichsgedanken der Römer. (Leipzig: Koehler & Amelang).
VOIGT 1871
Voigt, M. , Beilagen IX - XXI zu dem jus naturale, aequum et bonum und jus gentium der Römer. (Leipzig:Ernst Julius Günther).
WAGNER 1967
Wagner, N. , Getica: Untersuchungen zum Leben des Jordanes und zur frühen Geschichte der Goten. (Berlin: W. de Gruyter & Co.)
WEBSTER / BROWN 1997
Webster, L. /Brown, M. , The transformation of the Roman world, AD 400-900. (London: British Museum Press).
WHITE 1975
White, H. , Metahistory: The historical imagination in nineteenth-century Europe. (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press).
WIRTH 1997
Wirth,G. , „Rome and its Germanic partners in the fourth century“. In: Kingdoms of the Empire: The Integration of Barbarians in Late Antiquity, W.Pohl (ed.), 13-56.
WOLFRAM 2005
Wolfram, H. , The Roman Empire and its Germanic peoples. (Berkeley, Calif: Univ. of California Press).
ANCIENT SOURCES
AMMIANUS MARCELLINUS, Res Gestae
Ammianus Marcellinus/ Rolfe, J. C. (transl.) (1986) Ammiani Marcelini Rerum Gestarum Libri qui Supersunt 1-3. London: Heinemann (Loeb Classical Library)
IORDANES, Romana et Getica
Jordanes, Romana et Getica Berolini : Weidmann 1882. —LXXIII, (Monumenta Germaniae Historica. Auctores antiquissimi ; 5,1)
PROCOPIUS, History of the Wars
Procopius / Dewing,H.B. (transl.) (1962) Procopius of Caesarea. History of the Wars. London: Heinemann (Loeb Classical Library)
ZOSIMUS,Nea Historia
Zosimus / Ridley, R. T. (transl.) (2006). New history. Sydney:
Refbacks
ISSN: 2360-266X