Page Header

  • Home
  • About
  • Login
  • Register
  • search
  • Current
  • Archives
  • Submissions
  • Announcements
Home / Vol 6, No 2 (2019) Van Lommel

STOICISM AND WAR WOUNDS: MUCIUS SCAEVOLA, SERGIUS SILUS AND QUINTUS SERTORIUS

Korneel Van Lommel

Abstract


Soldiers sustaining battle wounds was both an historical reality as a popular literary theme in the Late Republic and the Early Empire. Battle scars were often instrumentalised as tokens of bravery on the battlefield and equated with military honours, symbolising true virtus. In this paper we analyse how some ancient authors constructed the behaviour of injured soldiers in their writing based on stoic ideals such as an indifferent attitude towards damaged body parts. We further argue that these literary depictions served as powerful metaphorical exempla that had educative and moral purposes not restricted to a military context but in a broader sense, relevant for all aspects of life. The targeted readership was encouraged for introspection and to discern popular from philosophical views in their own frame of mind on achieving virtus. In addition, a stoic framework was cleverly selectively deployed against boasting soldiers and their ideological allies which proved to be very efficient.


Keywords


Roman soldiers; war wounds; stoicism; indifference; exempla; Mucius Scaevola; Sergius Silus; Quintus Sertorius

Full Text: PDF

DOI: 10.14795/j.v6i2.388

References

BAROIN 2002

Baroin, C., Les cicatrices ou la mémoire du corps. In: Moreau, P. (ed.), Corps Romains (Grenoble: Jérôme Millon), 27-46.

BAROIN 2010

Baroin, C., Intégrité du corps, maladie, mutilation et exclusion chez les magistrats et les sénateurs romains. In: Collard, F./Samama, E. (eds.), Handicaps et sociétés dans l’histoire (Paris: L'Harmattan), 49-68.

BARTON 1997

Barton, T.S., Power and knowledge. Astrology, physiognomics, and medicine under the Roman empire (Michigan: University of Michigan Press).

BEAGON 2002

Beagon, M., Beyond comparison: M. Sergius, fortunae victor. In: Clark, G./Rajak, T. (eds.), Philosophy and Power in the Graeco-Roman World (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 111-132.

BEAGON 2005

Beagon, M., The Elder Pliny on the human animal: Natural History Book 7 (Clarendon Ancient History Series) (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

BLACK/PRETES 2007

Black, R.S./Pretes, L., Victims and victors: representation of physical disability on the silver screen, Research & practice for persons with severe disabilities 32.1, 66-83.

CORBEILL 1996

Corbeill, A., Controlling laughter: political humor in the late Roman republic (Princeton - New Jersey: Princeton University Press).

DAVIS 2006

Davis, L.J., The disability studies reader (New York - London: Routledge).

DE LIBERO 2002a

De Libero, L., Mit eiserner Hand ins Amt? Kriegsversehrte Aristokraten zwischen Recht und Religion, Ausgrenzung und Integration. In: Spielvogel, J. (ed.), Res Publica Reperta: zur Verfassung und Gesellschaft der römischen Republik und des frühen Prinzipats, Festschrift für J. Bleicken zum 75 Geburtstag (Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag Stuttgart), 172-191.

DE LIBERO 2002b

De Libero, L., Dem Schicksal trotzen, Behinderten Aristokraten in Rom, Ancient History Bulletin 16, 75-93.

ELLIS/GOGGIN 2015

Ellis, K./Goggin, G., Disability and the media (London: Palgrave).

EVANS 1999

Evans, R.J., Displaying honourable scars: a Roman gimmick, Acta Classica 42, 77-94.

FLOWER 1996

Flower, H.I., Ancestor masks and aristocratic power in Roman culture (Oxford: Clarendon Press).

GEVAERT 2017

Gevaert, B., Perfect Roman bodies: the Stoic view. In: Laes, C. (ed.), Disability in antiquity (London: Routledge), 213-221.

HARRIS 1985

Harris, W.V., War and imperialism in republican Rome 327-70 B.C. (Oxford: Clarendon Press).

HEIKKINEN 1997

Heikkinen, R., A moral example in Seneca: C. Mucius Scaevola, the conqueror of bodily pain. In: Vaahtera, J./Vainio, R. (eds.), Utriusque linguae peritus. Studia in honorem Toivo Viljamaa (Turku: Turun yliopisto), 63-72.

HOLFORD-STREVENS 2003

Holford-Strevens, L., Aulus Gellius: an Antonine scholar and his achievement (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

KAMA 2004

Kama, A., Supercrips versus the pitiful handicapped: Reception of disabling images by disabled audience members, Communications: the European journal of communication research 29.4, 447-466.

KASTER 2005

Kaster, R.A., Emotion, restraint, and community in ancient Rome (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 84-103.

KATZ 1981

Katz, B.R., Dolor, invidia and misericordia in Sallust, Acta Classica 24, 71-85.

LAES 2011a

Laes, C., Niet moeders mooiste! Antieke oorlogsinvaliden, schoonheidsidealen en history of disability in de Romeinse Oudheid, Geschiedenis der Geneeskunde 15, 68-77.

LAES 2011b

Laes, C., How does one do the history of disability in antiquity? One thousand years of case studies, Medicina nei Secoli 23.3, 915-946.

LAES 1997

Laes, C., Hoe zie ik eruit? De antieken en de fysiognomiek, Hermeneus 69.4, 235-240.

LAES 2018

Laes, C., Disabilities and the disabled in the Roman world: a social and cultural history (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).

LANGLANDS 2018

Langlands, R., Exemplary ethics in ancient Rome (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).

LASCARATOS/LASCARATOS/KALANTZIS 2004

Lascaratos, J./Lascaratos, G./Kalantzis, G., The ophthalmic wound of Philip II of Macedonia (360-336 BCE), Survey of Ophthalmology 49.2, 256-261.

LEIGH 1995

Leigh, M., Wounding and popular rhetoric at Rome, The Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 40, 195-216.

LONG 2002

Long, A.A., Epictetus: a stoic and Socratic guide to life (Oxford: Clarendon Press).

LONG 2006

Long, A.A., From Epicurus to Epictetus: studies in Hellenistic and Roman philosophy (Oxford: Clarendon Press).

MCGUSHIN 1992

McGushin, P., Sallust, The Histories. Volume I. Books i-ii (Oxford: Clarendon Press).

MORGAN 1974

Morgan, M.G., Priests and physical fitness, Classical Quarterly 24, 137-141.

MOSER 2012

Moser, P.D., Epiktet – ein Porträt des Philosophen als behinderter Mensch. In: Breitwieser, R. (ed.), Behinderungen und Beeinträchtigungen / Disability and Impairment in Antiquity (Oxford: Archaeopress), 65-74.

NETTLESHIP 1883

Nettleship, H., The Noctes Atticae of Aulus Gellius, The American Journal of Philology 4.4, 391-415.

OGILVIE 1965

Ogilvie, R.M., A commentary on Livy books 1-5 (Oxford: Clarendon Press).

RILEY 2005

Riley, C.R., Disability and the media: prescriptions for change (Hanover: University Press of New England).

ROLLER 2018

Roller, M.B., Models from the past in Roman culture: a world of exempla (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).

SALAZAR 2000

Salazar, C.F., The treatment of war wounds in Graeco-Roman antiquity (Leiden: Brill).

SAMAMA 2013

Samama, E., A king walking with pain? On the textual and iconographical images of Philip II and other wounded kings. In: Laes, C./Goodey, C.F./Rose, M.L. (eds.), Disabilities in Roman antiquity: disparate bodies, a capite ad calcem (Leiden: Brill), 231–248.

SELLARS 2006

Sellars, J., Stoicism (Berkeley: University of California Press).

SHERMAN 2005

Sherman, N., Stoic warriors: the ancient philosophy behind the military mind (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

SWAIN 2004

Swain, S., Bilingualism and biculturalism in Antonine Rome: Apuleius, Fronto, and Gellius. In: Holford-Strevens, L./Vardi, A. (eds.), The worlds of Aulus Gellius (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 4-40.

VAN HOUDT 2001

Van Houdt, T., Het lichaam als teken. Mannen, vrouwen en ‘vrouwelijke’ mannen in de antieke fysiognomiek en retoriek. In: Wils, K. (ed.), Het lichaam (m/v) (Leuven: Universitaire Pers Leuven), 27-40.

VAN LOMMEL 2015

Van Lommel, K., Heroes and outcasts: ambiguous attitudes towards impaired and disfigured Roman veterans, Classical World 109.1, 91-117.

WEILER 2004

Weiler, I., Negative Kalokagathie. In: Mauritsch, P./Petermandl, W./Mauritsch-Bein, B. (eds.), Die Gegenwart der Antike. Ausgewählte Schriften zu Geschichte, Kultur, und Rezeption des Altertums (Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft), 325-348.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.

ISSN: 2360-266X

Journal Content

Browse
  • By Issue
  • By Author
  • By Title
Popular Articles »ONCE MORE ABOUT ANTONIA TRYPHAINA
25954 views since: 2014-07-30

»BEYOND THE DIGRESSION: AMMIANUS MARCELLINUS ON THE PERSIANS
22436 views since: 2016-12-30

»KEEPING THE SACRED LANDSCAPE BEAUTIFUL AND ELABORATE: MAINTENANCE OF SANCTUARIES IN ANCIENT GREECE
6734 views since: 2022-04-30

Article Tools
Abstract
Print this article
Indexing metadata
How to cite item
Finding References
Review policy
Email this article (Login required)
Email the author (Login required)
Notifications
  • View
  • Subscribe

People

  • » Scientific Committee
  • » Contact
  • » Editorial Team

Policies

  • » Focus and Scope
  • » Section Policies
  • » Peer Review Process
  • » Open Access Policy

Submissions

  • » Online Submissions
  • » Author Guidelines
  • » Copyright Notice
  • » Privacy Statement

Other

  • » Journal Sponsorship
  • » Site Map
  • » About this Publishing System
  • » Reviewer Index
Number of Visits: 30918

Font Size

Journal Help
Open Journal Systems

             
Support, and OJS Responsive Theme by:
OpenJournalSystems.com